search instagram arrow-down
Charles Johnston

Recent Posts

Follow Now That I'm Catholic on WordPress.com

Past articles

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 7,848 other followers

Blog Stats

Now That I’m Catholic Facebook

Follow me on Twitter

Translate

Question: Apologetics Using Scripture

Full question by Nikki:

What is the best way to counter Protestant questions about the Catholic faith with scripture references?

Answer:

It really depends on what the question is. For every objection there is scriptural basis for it. The Church doesn’t teach Sola Scriptura, we believe that tradition is also important to know the will of God, and so not all Catholic teachings will be found explicitly in the Bible, but they are all have foundational evidence in the Bible.

So it’s my opinion that all apologetic arguments need to start with authority. Because without establishing a baseline by what authority you come to conclusions when reading scripture, we can go in endless circles.

You can point out a verse that backs up your position, and then they counter with one that refutes yours. They offer a passage that condemns a Catholic teaching, then you return fire with one that reinforces it. This goes on ad infinitum.

But if you establish the fact that Christ is God, and God is the ultimate authority in the universe (Matthew 28:18), they will agree (and if they don’t agree you can just walk away now). Then you show that Christ promised to, and actually did establish a Church (Matthew 16:18).

Jesus also had 12 apostles whom he gave special authority over, and commissioned them to go as He had been sent by the Father (John 20:22) and even gave them the authority to forgive sins. Peter was the chief of the Apostles, and was given a special position of authority, that was most on displaying tue day of Pentecost (Acts 2) and the Council of Jerusalem (Acts 15).

These apostles had a special position of authority to teach the teach the truth and safeguard the Gospel (it was unwritten in the first decades of the Church, but spread without error because of the faithful witness of the Apostles and their successors).

The apostles also commissioned successors to carry on their office after their death. We see this in the election of Mathias (Acts 1) and when Paul ordained Timothy as a Bishop.

Protestants reject all authority except God, when it comes to matters of faith. Some may accept their own church authority for governance purposes, but not for teaching infallibly. When a Protestant interprets scripture, they believe the Holy Spirit will lead them into truth, and this is true, but not how they imagine. If the Holy Spirit was leading all readers of the Bible into truth, there wouldn’t be 30,000 Protestant denominations. But since there is no ultimate authority, they have no one to say they are wrong, because one opinion is no more valid than another.

When Catholics interpret scripture, we do so through the lens of 2000 years of faithful tradition to the teachings of the apostles, when we err, there is a magisterium to say we are wrong, and since it was established by Christ, we can have faith that it will guide us as long as we remain faithful to the teachings of the Apostles.

Every Catholic teaching rises and falls on this bedrock principle.

But in as with all apologetics and evangelism, we have to remember these priceless words of Saint Bernadette,

“My job is to inform, not to convince.”

We can lay out the best argument possible, but we cannot charge hearts, that job we have to entrust to God.

(I wrote this a few years ago about my own struggle with accepting Church Authority. https://nowthatimcatholic.com/2016/05/23/a-matter-of-authority/)

Advertisements

2 comments on “Question: Apologetics Using Scripture

  1. canach says:

    You are right. Only God can do the convincing. I finally wrote my conversion story for Coming Home Network. Thanks for giving me the idea. The link is on my latest blog post as well as a link to your story which made me want to write mine (I hope that’s okay). https://scotinprogress.com/2018/10/22/a-story/

    Like

    1. That’s great, I’ll take a look tonight. Of course you can link to anything on my site that you feel would help your readers understand the faith or your journey, or any reason at all lol. God bless.

      Like

Leave a Reply
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: